It’s been a while since I posted any recipes to my Tonya’s Diner section of When It Was Cool (not a real Diner obviously, it’s just the name of our recipe section). So, I thought I would go back through all the food recipes I’ve offered up so far and pick my 15 favorite recipes! I hope you and your family have as much fun cooking up these recipes as I had cooking them and eating them! Here are my 15 top recipes from the Tonya’s Diner section of When It Was Cool. Click on the links to get the full recipes!
1: Tres Leches Cake Recipe
Tres Leches cake, otherwise called as Three Milk Cake. Sweet and moist two layer cake with vanilla sponge cake base completely soaked in three kinds of milk, topped with whipped cream. Get the recipe!
2: Garlic Butter Steak and Potatoes Skillet Recipe
This was a delicious recipe! I can’t wait to make it again! It would also be great with chicken, or sliced pork chops, maybe even beef tips. Get the recipe!
3: Red Velvet Cake Recipe
An amazing and delicious Red Velvet cake made from scratch. Some people call it the yummiest red velvet cake recipe ever! Get the recipe!
4: Poor Man’s Soup Recipe
Made with ground beef, chilies, tomatoes, and more. This is a perfect heavy soup to warm you up and fill you up. This is a meal in a soup bowl! Get the recipe!
5: Pizza Casserole Recipe
This recipe has been in my family for many years now. I have cooked it for my two sons many times since they were wee little guys. They are young men now & still they love it.. I made it the other night for my husband & when I went back for leftovers the very next day someone had kindly saved me one spoonful...I hope you will try it & love it as much! This dish is a favorite of NoFriender of the Thrash Metal Show podcast! Get the recipe!
6: Chicken and Dumplins Recipe
Chicken Dumplins are a favorite among my crew. We ALL love them! In my opinion, this is the absolute BEST comfort food in the South of all time. This is my own recipe so there will not be a lot of actual measurements in here, I know it by a can of this and that and a pinch of this. Get the recipe!
7: Chocolate Éclair Dessert Recipe
Pudding, whipped topping, graham crackers, and more make this a delicious sweet recipe everyone will enjoy. One of the best desserts in all of Tonya’s Diner. Get the recipe!
8: Taco Soup Recipe
A simple, yet delicious combination of two all time favorites- taco and soup! This is another heavy soup recipe that is easy to make and even more fun to eat. Get the recipe!
9: Taco Spaghetti Recipe
I know, I know. This sound ridiculous. However, taco spaghetti is amazing and really fun to make. Everyone in the family will love it. Get the recipe!
10: Granny’s Southern Banana Puddin’ Recipe
This one takes some time as it is made entirely from scratch but is it ever worth it! If you are tired of store bought banana puddings then put some time and love into into Granny’s Southern Banana Puddin’ Recipe. Get the recipe!
11: Salisbury Steak Recipe
This one is a classic favorite. Have you ever had Salisbury steak? I mean something other than the microwave dinner variety? Then try this classic that Tonya has whipped up! Get the recipe!
12: S’mores Cobbler Recipe
This one is Karl’s favorite. It is super easy to make and a really sweet dessert. It takes no time to make and will become a memorable favorite. Just keep Karl away from it. Get the recipe!
13: Pizza Sliders Recipe
This is another one of Karl’s favorite recipes from the diner. Pizza sliders are a great sandwich snack and finger food. Easy to make. Get the recipe!
14: Southern Fried Tuna Patties Recipe
This is a home style recipe that is easy to make and delicious. Just wait until you try fresh made southern fried tuna patties. Get the recipe!
15: Peach Pecan Upside Down Cake Recipe
A unique dessert that is easy to make. Looking for a new sweet cake favorite? Try Tonya’s Peach Pecan Upside Down Cake recipe! Get the recipe!
If you found this article interesting consider becoming a Patreon supporter. That is how When It Was Cool keeps our website and podcasts online, plus you get lots of bonus content including extra and extended podcasts, articles, digital comics, ebooks, and much more. Check out our Patreon Page to see what's up!
If you don't want to use Patreon but still want to support When It Was Cool then how about a one time $5 PayPal donation? Thank you!
